VPN Subscription Costs Compared Over Several Years
Fourteen dollars and ninety-nine cents. That number has anchored the VPN market for roughly a decade, and it is the price quoted in most comparison articles as though it were a law of nature. The list price has barely moved. What has moved is everything around it: the discount ladder, the renewal clause, the currency conversion, the plan tiers that did not exist in 2015 and the ones that vanished by 2022. Comparing VPN subscription costs across several years turns out to be less a study of pricing than a study of packaging, and the packaging has changed far more than the number on the sticker.
Three providers dominate the consumer conversation: NordVPN, ExpressVPN, and Surfshark, with Proton VPN and Private Internet Access filling out most shortlists. Their advertised monthly rates for a two-year commitment sit in a narrow band, generally between two and five dollars. The spread looks trivial. It stops looking trivial once a subscriber tracks what actually leaves a bank account over four or five years, because the cheap headline rate applies to a first term only, and renewal pricing is where the arithmetic gets interesting.
The sticker price that never moved
In 2016, a one-year ExpressVPN plan ran about ninety-nine dollars, which worked out to roughly eight dollars and change per month. NordVPN's two-year deal hovered near seventy dollars for the first term. By 2020 those figures had shifted by a dollar or two in either direction, and by 2024 the headline entry prices were still recognizably the same products. A shopper comparing 2016 and 2024 advertisements side by side would conclude that VPN pricing had been frozen.
That conclusion is wrong in a specific way. The entry price held steady while the entry term lengthened. Two-year commitments became the default pitch, then thirty-month commitments, then bundles that threw in a password manager and cloud storage to make the per-month figure look smaller. The monthly number shrank because the denominator grew, not because the provider got cheaper. A four-dollar monthly rate spread across twenty-seven months is a larger total outlay than an eight-dollar rate across twelve.
Renewal is the number that matters
Every major provider discounts the first term and renews at a higher rate. This is disclosed, usually in small print near the checkout button, and it is the single largest source of cost variance over a multi-year horizon. A NordVPN two-year plan bought at promotional pricing can renew at a rate closer to standard monthly billing, which means the second term may cost two to three times the first. ExpressVPN has followed a similar pattern. The first invoice is a customer acquisition cost. The second invoice is the actual business model.
Tracking this across years exposes a quiet trend: renewal rates have crept upward faster than inflation in several cases. A subscriber who bought in 2018 and let the plan auto-renew through 2023 may have paid roughly double the introductory rate by the final year, without any single increase large enough to notice. The increases arrive in annual increments of a few dollars, buried in a renewal email that most people delete unread.
What the bundles actually cost
Surfshark deserves separate treatment because it pushed hardest on the bundle strategy. Its One plan folds in an antivirus, a password manager, and a data breach scanner. The per-month figure for the bundle looks competitive against a bare VPN from a rival. The comparison only holds if the subscriber would have bought those adjacent tools anyway. Most would not have. The bundle is a way to raise the total transaction while keeping the monthly headline low, and it works because shoppers compare monthly numbers and rarely compare total first-term outlays.
A fair multi-year comparison therefore has to strip the bundle back out. Priced as a standalone VPN, Surfshark's two-year rate has tracked close to NordVPN's, with the same first-term discount and the same renewal step-up. The add-ons are real software, not padding, but they inflate the average selling price in a way that muddies any clean comparison against a provider selling only the tunnel.
The quiet rise of monthly billing
Monthly plans have always existed and were always bad value, typically eleven to thirteen dollars. What changed around 2021 is that providers began advertising them more prominently, partly to satisfy app store billing rules and partly to capture subscribers who distrust long commitments. The monthly premium over an annual plan widened during this period. In 2016 the gap between monthly and annual billing was roughly forty percent. By 2024 it was frequently over sixty percent.
The monthly plan is now the most expensive way to buy a VPN by a wide margin, and the providers know it. It functions as a penalty rate for flexibility. A subscriber who wants to leave at any time pays for that privilege in cash, month after month, and the cumulative cost over two years can exceed a discounted multi-year plan by a factor of three or more.
Currency and tax lines that change the total
Prices are quoted in dollars, but a large share of subscribers pay in euros, pounds, or local currency through a card that adds a conversion fee. That fee, usually one to three percent, has been a constant across the years. What changed is the addition of sales tax and VAT collection at checkout. Providers began applying local tax to digital subscriptions in most jurisdictions during the late 2010s, which added roughly fifteen to twenty-five percent to the total in much of Europe and a smaller amount in many US states.
None of this appears in the advertised monthly rate. A plan pitched at three dollars a month can land as four dollars and change once tax and conversion settle. Over a five-year subscription the difference is not trivial, and it is one of the reasons two people on the same plan in different countries can pay materially different totals for identical service.
Free tiers and the price of not paying
Proton VPN maintains a genuinely free tier with no data cap, which makes it an outlier. Most other free VPNs are ad-supported or sell connection metadata, and their cost shows up in bandwidth limits, server congestion, and privacy terms rather than on an invoice. Comparing a free tier against a paid plan across several years is awkward because the free product has improved steadily. Proton's free servers have grown in number, and the paid Plus tier has moved from roughly four dollars a month on annual billing to a figure that has held remarkably stable, with occasional promotional dips.
The honest multi-year picture includes a category of cost that never appears in a price column: the value of the time spent comparing, cancelling before auto-renewal, and re-shopping every term to capture the new-customer discount again. That labor is the real recurring expense for anyone who refuses to pay renewal rates, and it has grown as the discount ladders have become more elaborate.
A four-year ledger, roughly
Take a hypothetical subscriber who signs up in early 2020 on a two-year promotional plan at roughly three dollars and fifty cents a month, pays about eighty-four dollars for the first term, then lets it renew in 2022 at a rate closer to seven dollars a month, or about a hundred and seventy dollars for the second term. Add tax and conversion at roughly eighteen percent across both terms. The four-year total lands somewhere near three hundred dollars. A subscriber who instead bought monthly at twelve dollars the whole time would have paid five hundred and seventy-six dollars before tax.
The spread between the smartest and worst buying strategies over four years is roughly two to one, and the gap has widened since 2016 because the discount for long commitments grew while the monthly penalty rate rose alongside it. The headline monthly price barely moved. The dispersion around it roughly doubled.
Where the trend points next
Two forces are pushing in opposite directions. On one side, competition from bundled privacy suites and from free tiers keeps entry prices low and forces providers to keep discounting the first term. On the other, the cost of running a global server network has risen with energy prices and bandwidth demand, and providers have responded by raising renewal rates and shortening the promotional window. The result is a market where the advertised number is increasingly decorative and the renewal invoice is the real price.
A subscriber looking at a five-year horizon should expect the first term to cost roughly half of what the later terms cost, and should plan to re-shop or negotiate at each renewal. The providers have built their economics around the assumption that most people will not. The gap between the advertised monthly rate and the amount actually paid over several years is now the defining feature of VPN pricing, and it shows no sign of closing.


